Lessons and exercises follow the school system and stay in its language.Les leçons et les exercices suivent le système scolaire et restent dans sa langue.Lektionen und Übungen folgen dem Schulsystem und bleiben in seiner Sprache.

Roots and irrational numbers

Print the topic

Every lesson of the topic, from the first year to the last, ready for paper. Exercise sets are lettered A, B, C… and answered at the end.

To save a PDF, choose “Save as PDF” in the print dialog.

1. Square roots and cube roots

Warm-up

Three quick questions from earlier lessons.

  1. 33⋅34=3?3^{ 3 } \cdot 3^{ 4 } = 3^{?}. What is the exponent?
  2. 68÷62=6?6^{ 8 } \div 6^{ 2 } = 6^{?}. What is the exponent?
  3. (83)3=8?\left(8^{ 3 }\right)^{ 3 } = 8^{?}. What is the exponent?

Discover

A square tile has an area of 49 cm². How long is a side?

  1. 7 cm
  2. 24.5 cm

Key idea

Square roots undo squaring; cube roots undo cubing.

a\sqrt{a} is the positive number whose square is aa (the side of a square of area aa). a3\sqrt[3]{a} is the number whose cube is aa (the edge of a cube of volume aa). If aa is not a perfect square, a\sqrt{a} lies between two consecutive whole numbers.

Worked example

30\sqrt{30} and 643\sqrt[3]{64}.

5<30<65 < \sqrt{30} < 6
25 < 30 < 36.
643=4\sqrt[3]{64} = 4
4 · 4 · 4 = 64.

Your turn, guided

Your turn: the edge of a cube of volume 125.

55
5³ = 125.

Practice ★

  1. A square has an area of 25 square units. How long is its side?
  2. A square has an area of 676 square units. How long is its side?
  1. A cube has a volume of 27 cubic units. How long is each edge?

Watch out!

Practice ★★

  1. 11\sqrt{ 11 } lies between two consecutive whole numbers. What is the smaller one?
  2. 682\sqrt{ 682 } lies between two consecutive whole numbers. What is the smaller one?

Exit ticket

Three questions to check you have got it.

  1. A square has an area of 25 square units. How long is its side?
  2. A square has an area of 676 square units. How long is its side?
  3. A square has an area of 64 square units. How long is its side?

Summary card

Square and cube roots

a\sqrt{a}: side of a square of area aa; a3\sqrt[3]{a}: edge of a cube of volume aa.

Watch out: a root is not half or a third.

One more step is optional: a challenge. Try it, or finish the lesson now.

Challenge ★★★

  1. How many whole numbers n≥1n \ge 1 satisfy n<9\sqrt{n} < 9?

2. Rational and irrational numbers; repeating decimals

Warm-up

Three quick questions from earlier lessons.

  1. A square has an area of 25 square units. How long is its side?
  2. 11\sqrt{ 11 } lies between two consecutive whole numbers. What is the smaller one?
  3. A cube has a volume of 27 cubic units. How long is each edge?

Discover

13=0.333…\tfrac{1}{3} = 0.333\ldots goes on forever. Is it rational?

  1. Yes
  2. No: it never ends

Key idea

Rational numbers are fractions; their decimals end or repeat.

A rational number can be written ab\tfrac{a}{b} with integers aa, b≠0b \neq 0; its decimal expansion terminates or repeats. An irrational number cannot: its decimal never ends and never repeats. n\sqrt{n} is irrational unless nn is a perfect square; π\pi is irrational.

Worked example

Write 0.27‾0.\overline{27} as a fraction.

100x=27.2727…100x = 27.2727\ldots
Let x = 0.2727…
99x=2799x = 27
Subtract x.
x=2799=311x = \tfrac{27}{99} = \tfrac{3}{11}
Simplify.

Your turn, guided

Your turn: write 0.5‾0.\overline{5} as a fraction.

59\tfrac{5}{9}
10x − x = 5.

Practice ★

  1. Which number is irrational?
    1. 2\sqrt{ 2 }
    2. 4\sqrt{ 4 }
    3. 0.1‾0.\overline{ 1 }
  2. Which number is irrational?
    1. 10\sqrt{ 10 }
    2. 16\sqrt{ 16 }
    3. 0.3‾0.\overline{ 3 }
  1. Write 0.1‾0.\overline{ 1 } (the digit 1 repeating forever) as a fraction.

Watch out!

Practice ★★

  1. Write 0.48‾0.\overline{ 48 } (the digits 48 repeating forever) as a fraction.
  2. Write 0.70‾0.\overline{ 70 } (the digits 70 repeating forever) as a fraction.

Exit ticket

Three questions to check you have got it.

  1. Write 0.1‾0.\overline{ 1 } (the digit 1 repeating forever) as a fraction.
  2. Write 0.2‾0.\overline{ 2 } (the digit 2 repeating forever) as a fraction.
  3. Write 0.8‾0.\overline{ 8 } (the digit 8 repeating forever) as a fraction.

Summary card

Rational and irrational

Ends or repeats: rational. Neither: irrational.

Watch out: a repeating decimal is a fraction over 9, 99, …

One more step is optional: a challenge. Try it, or finish the lesson now.

Challenge ★★★

  1. Write 0.18‾0.1\overline{ 8 } (only the digit 8 repeats) as a fraction.

3. Fractions closer and closer to √2

Discover

32=1.5\dfrac{3}{2} = 1.5, 75=1.4\dfrac{7}{5} = 1.4, 1712≈1.4167\dfrac{17}{12} \approx 1.4167, 4129≈1.4138\dfrac{41}{29} \approx 1.4138. These fractions get closer to which number?

  1. 2≈1.41421\sqrt{2} \approx 1.41421
  2. 1.51.5

Key idea

Fractions closer and closer to 2\sqrt{2}.

Start with pq=11\dfrac{p}{q} = \dfrac{1}{1} and repeat

pq→p+2qp+q\dfrac{p}{q} \to \dfrac{p + 2q}{p + q}.

The fractions get as close to 2\sqrt{2} as we wish, but none is equal to it: 2\sqrt{2} is irrational.

Worked example

Next fraction after 1712\dfrac{17}{12}:

17+2417+12=4129\dfrac{17 + 24}{17 + 12} = \dfrac{41}{29}
p=17p = 17, q=12q = 12.
412=168141^2 = 1681, 2×292=16822 \times 29^2 = 1682: almost equal
Check.

Your turn, guided

Your turn: find the fraction after 75\dfrac{7}{5}.

1712\dfrac{17}{12}
7+107+5\dfrac{7 + 10}{7 + 5}.

Practice ★

  1. Apply one step 169→p+2qp+q\dfrac169 \to \dfrac{p + 2q}{p + q} to 169\dfrac{ 16 }{ 9 }. Give the new fraction.
  2. Apply one step 109→p+2qp+q\dfrac109 \to \dfrac{p + 2q}{p + q} to 109\dfrac{ 10 }{ 9 }. Give the new fraction.
  3. Apply one step 1615→p+2qp+q\dfrac1615 \to \dfrac{p + 2q}{p + q} to 1615\dfrac{ 16 }{ 15 }. Give the new fraction.

Practice ★★

  1. How good is 2015\dfrac{ 20 }{ 15 } as an approximation of 2\sqrt{2}? Compute p2−2q2p^2 - 2q^2 (the closer to 0, the better).
  2. How good is 1914\dfrac{ 19 }{ 14 } as an approximation of 2\sqrt{2}? Compute p2−2q2p^2 - 2q^2 (the closer to 0, the better).

Exit ticket

Two questions to check.

  1. Apply one step 169→p+2qp+q\dfrac169 \to \dfrac{p + 2q}{p + q} to 169\dfrac{ 16 }{ 9 }. Give the new fraction.
  2. Apply one step 109→p+2qp+q\dfrac109 \to \dfrac{p + 2q}{p + q} to 109\dfrac{ 10 }{ 9 }. Give the new fraction.

Summary card

Approaching √2

  • pq→p+2qp+q\dfrac{p}{q} \to \dfrac{p + 2q}{p + q}.
  • p2p^2 and 2q22q^2 always differ by exactly 1.

Computers store 2\sqrt{2} only approximately: every stored number is a fraction.

4. History of irrational numbers: from Babylon to Dedekind

Discover

Babylonian scribes wrote 2\sqrt{2} as about 1.4142131.414213, nearly 4,000 years ago. Later, Greek mathematicians proved something surprising about 2\sqrt{2}. What?

  1. It can never be written exactly as a fraction
  2. It is exactly 1.4142131.414213

Key idea

Numbers that are not fractions.

2000 BCE1000 BCE11000c. 1725 BCETablet YBC 7289c. 1725 BCETablet YBC 7289
  1. Step 12000 BCE1000 BCE11000c. 1725 BCETablet YBC 7289c. 1725 BCETablet YBC 7289About 1800–1650 BC: a Babylonian tablet gives √2 ≈ 1.414213.
  2. Step 22000 BCE1000 BCE11000c. 1725 BCETablet YBC 7289c. 430 BCETheodorusc. 1725 BCETablet YBC 7289c. 430 BCETheodorusTheodorus of Cyrene c. 465 – c. 398 BCNo portrait is knownTheodorus (born 465 BC) shows that √3, √5, …, √17 are irrational.
  3. Step 32000 BCE1000 BCE11000c. 1725 BCETablet YBC 7289c. 430 BCETheodorus1872Dedekindc. 1725 BCETablet YBC 7289c. 430 BCETheodorus1872DedekindRichard Dedekind 1831–1916Unknown artist. Public domain1872: Dedekind defines irrational numbers precisely with 'cuts'.

The Babylonian tablet YBC 7289 (about 1800–1650 BC) gives 2≈1.414213\sqrt{2} \approx 1.414213. Greek mathematicians proved that 2\sqrt{2} is not a fraction, some say Pythagoras himself; Theodorus (born 465 BC) showed the same for 3,5,…,17\sqrt{3}, \sqrt{5}, \dots, \sqrt{17}. In 1872 Dedekind's Continuity and Irrational Numbers gave irrational numbers a precise definition.

Worked example

Why can't 2=pq\sqrt{2} = \dfrac{p}{q} (in lowest terms)?

p2=2q2p^2 = 2q^2, so pp is even: p=2rp = 2r
Square it.
q2=2r2q^2 = 2r^2: qq is even too, a contradiction
Then 4r2=2q24r^2 = 2q^2.

Practice ★

  1. What did Dedekind publish in 1872?
    1. A precise definition of irrational numbers
    2. The first value of √2
    3. The proof that √2 is irrational
  1. Theodorus showed that 3,…,17\sqrt{3}, \dots, \sqrt{17} are irrational when the number is not a perfect square. Between which two whole numbers is 17\sqrt{ 17 }? Give the smaller one.
  2. Theodorus showed that 3,…,17\sqrt{3}, \dots, \sqrt{17} are irrational when the number is not a perfect square. Between which two whole numbers is 5\sqrt{ 5 }? Give the smaller one.
  1. Like the Babylonian tablet: a square has side 80. Find its diagonal with 2≈1.414\sqrt{2} \approx 1.414.

Summary card

Irrational numbers today

  • π\pi, 2\sqrt{2} and ee appear in every science.
  • Paper sizes A4, A3…: the ratio of the sides is 2\sqrt{2}.
  • Calculators show only an approximation of an irrational number.

Sources: MacTutor article on Pythagoras's theorem in Babylonian mathematics; biographies of Theodorus and Dedekind (see "Sources and credits").