History of limits: Bolzano, Cauchy and Weierstrass

Lessons and exercises follow the school system and stay in its language.Les leçons et les exercices suivent le système scolaire et restent dans sa langue.Lektionen und Übungen folgen dem Schulsystem und bleiben in seiner Sprache.

About this lesson

Precalculus › Limits: an introduction

To save a PDF, choose “Save as PDF” in the print dialog.

Sources and credits

Written with this source as a starting point:

sedifier rewrote the text and added its own examples and exercises.

Written with AI assistance; every answer is checked by our math engine. Not yet reviewed by a teacher.

This lesson: CC BY-SA 4.0, © sedifier · All credits

History of limits: Bolzano, Cauchy and Weierstrass

Limits: an introduction. limits, one-sided limits, limits at infinity, infinite limits, continuity, 0/0

Discover

For 150 years after Newton and Leibniz, calculus worked, but nobody could say exactly what a limit was. People spoke of 'infinitely small' quantities. Why was that a problem?

  1. Some arguments gave contradictions, so the foundations were shaky
  2. Calculations were too slow

Key idea

Making limits precise.

18201840186018801817Bolzano1817Bolzano
  1. Step 118201840186018801817Bolzano1817BolzanoBernard Bolzano 1781–1848Unknown artist. Public domain1817: Bolzano proves the intermediate value theorem without 'infinitely small' quantities.
  2. Step 218201840186018801817Bolzano1821Cauchy1817Bolzano1821CauchyAugustin-Louis Cauchy 1789–1857Jean Roller (1798–1866), about 1840. Public domain1821: Cauchy's Cours d'analyse builds calculus as rigorously as possible.
  3. Step 318201840186018801817Bolzano1821Cauchy1872Weierstrass1817Bolzano1821Cauchy1872WeierstrassKarl Weierstraß 1815–1897Unknown artist. Public domain1872: Weierstrass's function: continuous everywhere, differentiable nowhere.

In 1817 Bolzano proved the intermediate value theorem without infinitely small quantities. In 1821 Cauchy's Cours d'analyse developed the basic theorems of calculus as rigorously as possible. In 1872 Weierstrass found a function that is continuous everywhere but has a derivative nowhere.

Source

When the values successively given to the same variable approach a fixed value indefinitely, so as to end by differing from it as little as one wishes, this last value is called the limit of all the others.

Augustin-Louis Cauchy, Course in Analysis, 1821 (our translation from French)

For Cauchy, when is a fixed value the limit?

  1. When the values end up as close to it as one wishes
  2. When the variable ends up equal to it

Worked example

Today's idea: f(x)→Lf(x) \to L as x→ax \to a if f(x)f(x) gets as close to LL as we wish when xx is close enough to aa. Example: f(x)=3xf(x) = 3x, a=2a = 2.

3∣x−2∣<0.033|x - 2| < 0.03
We want ∣3x−6∣<0.03|3x - 6| < 0.03.
∣x−2∣<0.01|x - 2| < 0.01
Close enough means:

Practice ★

  1. What did Weierstrass find in 1872?
    1. A function continuous everywhere but differentiable nowhere
    2. The derivative
    3. The number e
  1. In Cauchy's spirit: for f(x)=6xf(x) = 6x, how close must xx be to 1 so that ∣f(x)−6∣<0.05|f(x) - 6| < 0.05? Give the largest distance δ\delta.
  2. In Cauchy's spirit: for f(x)=9xf(x) = 9x, how close must xx be to 1 so that ∣f(x)−9∣<0.09|f(x) - 9| < 0.09? Give the largest distance δ\delta.
  1. Bolzano proved the intermediate value theorem in 1817. f(x)=x3−64f(x) = x^3 - 64 is continuous with f(0)<0f(0) < 0 and f(5)>0f(5) > 0. Find the zero it guarantees.

Summary card

Limits today

  • Every derivative and integral is defined by a limit.
  • Numerical methods stop when successive results are 'close enough': a limit in practice.
  • Engineers ask how close an approximation is: the same question as Cauchy's.

Sources: MacTutor biographies of Bolzano, Cauchy and Weierstrass (see "Sources and credits").

End of the lesson

Sources and credits

Written with this source as a starting point:

sedifier rewrote the text and added its own examples and exercises.

Written with AI assistance; every answer is checked by our math engine. Not yet reviewed by a teacher.

This lesson: CC BY-SA 4.0, © sedifier · All credits