Warm-up
Three quick questions from earlier lessons.
- A school has 600 juniors and 300 seniors. A stratified sample of 90 students is taken in proportion to grade. How many juniors are in the sample?
- A systematic sample of 28 customers is taken from a list of 140: a random start, then every th name. What is ?
- A district has 60 classrooms. Five are chosen at random and every student in them is surveyed. Which sampling method is this?
- Cluster sampling
- Stratified sampling
- A simple random sample of students
Discover
A randomized experiment on 50 volunteer athletes shows a supplement improves sprint times. Can you say it helps all adults?
- No, only for these volunteers
- Yes, it was a randomized experiment
Key idea
Two kinds of randomness, two kinds of conclusions.
Worked example
Four studies.
Your turn, guided
Your turn: how many of the four combinations (sampling yes/no × assignment yes/no) allow a causal conclusion about the whole population?
Practice ★
- A random sample of 493 adults in a city shows that those who walk to work report less stress. No treatment was assigned. What can be concluded?
- The association can be generalized to adults in the city, but not cause and effect
- Walking causes less stress for adults in the city
- Nothing beyond the 493 people sampled
- 147 volunteers are randomly assigned to a new or old teaching method; the new method scores higher. What can be concluded?
- The method caused the difference for these volunteers; generalizing beyond them is risky
- The new method works better for all students
- Nothing, because there was no random sample
Watch out!
Practice ★★
- In a drug trial with 64 patients, neither the patients nor the doctors who assess them know who receives the drug. What is this called?
- A double-blind experiment
- A placebo
- Blocking
Exit ticket
Three questions to check you have got it.
- A random sample of 493 adults in a city shows that those who walk to work report less stress. No treatment was assigned. What can be concluded?
- The association can be generalized to adults in the city, but not cause and effect
- Walking causes less stress for adults in the city
- Nothing beyond the 493 people sampled
- A random sample of 530 adults in a city shows that those who walk to work report less stress. No treatment was assigned. What can be concluded?
- The association can be generalized to adults in the city, but not cause and effect
- Walking causes less stress for adults in the city
- Nothing beyond the 530 people sampled
- A random sample of 712 adults in a city shows that those who walk to work report less stress. No treatment was assigned. What can be concluded?
- The association can be generalized to adults in the city, but not cause and effect
- Walking causes less stress for adults in the city
- Nothing beyond the 712 people sampled
Summary card
Scope of inference
- Random sampling → generalize.
- Random assignment → cause.
Watch out: you need both for a causal claim about a population.
One more step is optional: a challenge. Try it, or finish the lesson now.
Challenge ★★★
- In a random sample of 200 adults from a city of 17000, 50 walk to work. Estimate how many adults in the city walk to work.