History of significance tests: Arbuthnot, Pearson and Fisher

Lessons and exercises follow the school system and stay in its language.Les leçons et les exercices suivent le système scolaire et restent dans sa langue.Lektionen und Übungen folgen dem Schulsystem und bleiben in seiner Sprache.

About this lesson

Statistics (AP-aligned) › Significance tests

To save a PDF, choose “Save as PDF” in the print dialog.

Sources and credits

Written with this source as a starting point:

  • MacTutor History of Mathematics (Biographies of John Arbuthnot, Karl Pearson and Ronald Aylmer Fisher), by J J O'Connor, E F Robertson and others, University of St Andrews, CC BY-SA 4.0
  • Wikidata (Portrait (main image, P18), name and life dates), by Wikidata contributors, Wikimedia Foundation, CC0 1.0

sedifier rewrote the text and added its own examples and exercises.

Written with AI assistance; every answer is checked by our math engine. Not yet reviewed by a teacher.

This lesson: CC BY-SA 4.0, © sedifier · All credits

History of significance tests: Arbuthnot, Pearson and Fisher

Significance tests.

Discover

Records from 1629 to 1710 showed slightly more boys than girls born. In 1710 John Arbuthnot asked: could chance alone explain that? Suppose boys outnumbered girls in every one of those years.

  1. Hardly: that would be like 82 heads in a row
  2. Yes, easily

Key idea

Testing hypotheses, from baptisms to fields.

1700175018001850190019501710Arbuthnot1710Arbuthnot
  1. Step 11700175018001850190019501710Arbuthnot1710ArbuthnotJohn Arbuthnot 1667–1735Godfrey Kneller, 1723. Public domain1710: Arbuthnot's paper on male and female births, a first test of significance.
  2. Step 21700175018001850190019501710Arbuthnot1900Pearson1710Arbuthnot1900PearsonKarl Pearson 1857–1936Unknown artist, 1910. Public domain1900: Pearson's chi-square test.
  3. Step 31700175018001850190019501710Arbuthnot1900Pearson1935Fisher1710Arbuthnot1900Pearson1935FisherRonald Fisher 1890–1962Barry Eagel, 1952. Barry Eagel. CC BY-SA 4.01935: Fisher's The Design of Experiments.

In 1710 John Arbuthnot (1667–1735) studied the slight excess of male births over female births from 1629 to 1710, perhaps the first application of probability to social statistics and the first formal test of significance. In 1900 Karl Pearson published the chi-square test. At Rothamsted, Ronald Fisher developed the design and analysis of experiments.

Worked example

Arbuthnot's reasoning in numbers: how many years from 1629 to 1710, inclusive?

1710−1629+1=821710 - 1629 + 1 = 82
Suppose more boys every year: count the years.
(12)82≈2×10−25\left(\tfrac{1}{2}\right)^{82} \approx 2 \times 10^{-25}
Probability by chance alone.

Practice ★

  1. What did Arbuthnot study in his 1710 paper?
    1. The excess of male over female births
    2. Fertilizers on randomized plots
    3. The chi-square test
  1. Like Arbuthnot: if each year were a fair 'coin flip' between more boys and more girls, what is the probability (as a fraction) of more boys 5 years in a row?
  2. Like Arbuthnot: if each year were a fair 'coin flip' between more boys and more girls, what is the probability (as a fraction) of more boys 10 years in a row?
  1. Pearson's chi-square: one category has expected count 10 and observed count 12. Compute its contribution (O−E)2E\dfrac{(O - E)^2}{E}.

Summary card

Significance tests today

  • Medicine: does a new drug work better than a placebo?
  • Websites: does a new design get more clicks (A/B tests)?
  • Quality control: is a machine still making parts to specification?

Sources: MacTutor biographies of Arbuthnot, Pearson and Fisher (see "Sources and credits").

End of the lesson

Sources and credits

Written with this source as a starting point:

  • MacTutor History of Mathematics (Biographies of John Arbuthnot, Karl Pearson and Ronald Aylmer Fisher), by J J O'Connor, E F Robertson and others, University of St Andrews, CC BY-SA 4.0
  • Wikidata (Portrait (main image, P18), name and life dates), by Wikidata contributors, Wikimedia Foundation, CC0 1.0

sedifier rewrote the text and added its own examples and exercises.

Written with AI assistance; every answer is checked by our math engine. Not yet reviewed by a teacher.

This lesson: CC BY-SA 4.0, © sedifier · All credits