Warm-up
Three quick questions from earlier lessons.
- Researchers randomly assign 66 volunteers to drink coffee or water, then test their reaction times. What kind of study is it?
- An experiment: the researchers assign the treatment
- An observational study
- A sample survey
- Children with bigger shoes read better (16% higher scores). What is the most likely explanation?
- A confounding variable: age affects both shoe size and reading
- Bigger feet improve reading
- It must be pure chance
- An observational study of 3416 adults finds that those who eat breakfast weigh less. Does this show that eating breakfast causes lower weight?
- No: other differences between the groups could explain it
- Yes, because the sample is large
- Yes, if the association is strong
Discover
To compare two fertilizers, you put fertilizer A on the sunny half of a field and B on the shady half. A grows better. What is the flaw?
- Sunlight, not the fertilizer, could explain the difference
- There is no flaw
Key idea
Principles of experimental design.
Worked example
Test 2 doses × 3 diets on 60 rats.
Your turn, guided
Your turn: 3 temperatures × 4 times. Number of treatments.
Practice ★
- Why are 196 subjects assigned to the treatments at random?
- To balance other variables between the groups, so differences can be blamed on the treatment
- So the results apply to the whole population
- To give every subject the same chance of being in the study
- An experiment tests 2 fertilizer types at 3 watering levels, with every combination used. How many treatments are there?
- An experiment tests 9 fertilizer types at 12 watering levels, with every combination used. How many treatments are there?
Watch out!
Practice ★★
- A test of two diets on 115 adults first splits them into men and women, then randomizes diets within each group. What is this design?
- A randomized block design, blocking by sex
- A stratified random sample
- A completely randomized design
Exit ticket
Three questions to check you have got it.
- An experiment tests 2 fertilizer types at 3 watering levels, with every combination used. How many treatments are there?
- An experiment tests 9 fertilizer types at 12 watering levels, with every combination used. How many treatments are there?
- An experiment tests 8 fertilizer types at 9 watering levels, with every combination used. How many treatments are there?
Summary card
Experimental design
Compare · randomize · replicate · block. Treatments = combinations of factor levels.
Watch out: blocks (experiments) vs strata (samples).
One more step is optional: a challenge. Try it, or finish the lesson now.
Challenge ★★★
- An experiment crosses 2 fertilizers with 2 watering levels, and each treatment is used on 3 plants. How many plants are needed?